Focus Turns to Clinton’s Health After Disclosure of Pneumonia Diagnosis

Screen Shot 2016-09-12 at 07.37.11MAGGIE HABERMAN

Monday, September 12, 2016


Good Monday morning.
The topic of Hillary Clinton’s health, about which her opponent, Donald J. Trump, and his supporters have raised questions for months, was thrust into the center of the campaign on Sunday, after the Democratic nominee abruptly left a Sept. 11 memorial ceremony feeling ill. Her aides, who said when she left that she was “overheated,” later provided a doctor’s note saying that she received a diagnosis of pneumonia days earlier and had become dehydrated.
Mrs. Clinton canceled a trip to California late Sunday night, and it remains to be seen how long she will be off the campaign trail.
But Mrs. Clinton, 68, and Mr. Trump, 70, are likely to face calls for far more detailed medical records than they have provided. In Mr. Trump’s case, the extent of his release so far has been a widely mocked doctor’s note consisting of a few lines and praise for his “strength and stamina.” Mr. Trump is also set to appear on an episode of “The Dr. Oz Show” this week to discuss his health.
Mrs. Clinton, who sustained a concussion in December 2012 after becoming dehydrated, fainting and hitting her head on a toilet, learned she had pneumonia on Friday, according to the note from her doctor. She attended a fund-raiser later that night and went ahead with plans to attend the Ground Zero ceremony on Sunday. But she left earlier than planned, and aides said she was overheated. After videos emerged on Twitter of Mrs. Clinton leaning against a post to stand upright and nearly collapsing as she entered her van, her aides released the doctor’s note.
Many of Mrs. Clinton’s supporters said privately that they believed she would have been criticized whatever path she chose. If she had skipped the ceremony, she risked feeding conspiracies about her health that Mr. Trump has helped fan. But by attending, she risked getting sicker. Pneumonia, particularly in people older than 65, can be challenging to recuperate from, and Mrs. Clinton continued to campaign despite her illness over the course of several days.
But most of those supporters also acknowledged that by not revealing she had pneumonia immediately after the sick spell Sunday morning, she had fed the perception that her campaign was secretive.
That perception has helped bring down Mrs. Clinton’s numbers in polling when voters are asked whether they see her as “honest and trustworthy.” The numbers began to sag in 2015 when her use of a private email server while she was the secretary of state became public.
Mr. Trump proved unusually restrained, lasting several hours without posting something referring to Mrs. Clinton’s illness on Twitter. It remains to be seen whether he can hold to that level of discipline as the week begins. In addition to not releasing his medical records, Mr. Trump, citing an audit he claims he is in the middle of, has declined to release his tax returns, and he has sought to avoid a number of other levels of scrutiny, a source of frustration for the Clinton campaign.

Eric Thayer for The New York Times

The statement from her physician came after Mrs. Clinton abruptly left a ceremony in New York marking the 15th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks.

Marine recruits awaiting their lunch at boot camp at the Marine Corps Recruit Depot, Parris Island, in South Carolina in 2013.

Eric Thayer for The New York Times

Here are some facts about the illness: what it is, what it does and how people recover.

President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia, center, arrived at the Group of 20 meeting in Hangzhou, China, with the Chinese president, Xi Jinping, left, and President Nursultan Nazarbayev of Kazakhstan, right.

Pool photo by Alexei Druzhinin

President Vladimir V. Putin shows skill at rallying the support of the Russian public no matter what the circumstances.

Donald J. Trump on Thursday at Cleveland Arts and Social Sciences Academy, where he promised $20 billion to poor students.

Eric Thayer for The New York Times

Criticisms over a prime-time event hosted by Matt Lauer foreshadow the scrutiny, and anxiety, facing the anchors presiding over three Trump-Clinton debates.

On the Trail

Mr. Trump will speak at the National Guard Association in Baltimore, and he will host a rally in Asheville, N.C.
Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia will speak at a rally in Dayton, Ohio.
Damon Winter/The New York Times
On 9/11 Anniversary, Somber Reflections
Relatives of those who died in the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, gathered in Lower Manhattan, at the Pentagon and in Shanksville, Pa., to commemorate the 15th anniversary.
Donald J. Trump at the commander in chief in New York on Wednesday. He will visit a charter school in Cleveland on Thursday.

Against a Backdrop of War, Ad Portrays Donald Trump as Reckless


The latest ad from the “super PAC” supporting Hillary Clinton presents her rival’s foreign policy positions as a danger to the country.

Gary Johnson, the Libertarian Party presidential nominee, at a campaign rally on Saturday at Grand View University in Des Moines.

Michelle Obama Brings Voters’ Trust to Hillary Clinton’s Campaign


Mrs. Obama will put her broad popularity and reputation for authenticity to work this week for a candidate who has suffered from a lack of both.

Donald J. Trump, the Republican presidential nominee, spoke on Saturday at the funeral service for the conservative activist Phyllis Schlafly.

Donald Trump Praises Phyllis Schlafly as a Conservative ‘Hero’ at Her Funeral


Mr. Trump suggested that he and Mrs. Schlafly were kindred spirits in a shared fight as he addressed mourners on Saturday.

What We’re Reading Elsewhere

Mrs. Clinton’s saying that half of Mr. Trump’s supporters belong in a “basket of deplorables” sounds like “a category Miss Jean Brodie might have summoned up for some underperforming students,” The New Yorker writes.
The Washington Post compiled excerpts from articles to compare how the news media covered Mrs. Clinton and Mr. Trump after the Sept. 11 attacks.
A new Wall Street Journal/NBC News/Marist poll finds that Mrs. Clinton and Mr. Trump are deadlocked in Nevada and New Hampshire, counting them among 2016’s battleground states.